Progress | Centre-left Labour politics

Tax on strivers?

Today’s PMQs were lively as expected with the main focus being on the government’s proposed one per cent benefit cut, especially its effect on the working poor. The Tories were also gleeful about the numbers released this morning showing that unemployment figures were going down – but, as we know, that doesn’t tell the full story of unemployment. For me, biggest surprise was how personal and vindictive David Cameron behaved today, especially towards Ed Balls.

Who won?

It was a very intense exchange between Cameron and Ed Miliband with lots of jeers and boos from both sides of the house. The first question from Miliband seemed quite awkward with him reluctantly having to congratulate the government on unemployment. But from the second question on, Ed really was on fire over the benefits cap – he tried to get Cameron to admit that the majority of people affected by the cap are in work, but he just dodged the question. Miliband came back with solid stats to back up his point that the majority affected are in work. He attempted to frame the cap as a ‘tax on strivers’ – what the benefit cap effectively is for people in work.

Cameron’s responses to Miliband on the ‘tax on strivers’ line was to repeatedly state that government was taking low-wage earners out of paying income tax. Another main theme of Cameron’s answers was to frame Labour as the ‘pro-welfare’, without reform, party, a common misperception of Labour which we must be careful to get away from – if Cameron gets that message across to the public it is bad news for Labour.

What struck me was the personal hatred Cameron had for Balls. With a few off-the-cuff remarks, including calling him a bully, it got rather personal and nasty. This made Cameron appear aggressive and, to an extent, unprofessional. Miliband seemed to be on the ball today and able to easily cite relevant statistics in his responses with some quite witty lines. I will have to give the winner of today’s PMQs to Miliband based on his performance – but that’s not to say we have won the debate on the benefit cap.

Best backbencher?

This is a tricky one as plenty of good questions were asked, though many were about the unemployment figures or the benefit cap. Emily Thornberry asked an important question on child poverty and it was also good to hear from new MP Lucy Powell. I think the winner will have to be Dennis Skinner, even though I often disagree with him politically. He asked a question on the proposed new surveillance laws and said it would mean the government spying on more people than the press barons – which got his point over very well.

Best joke?

I have to give it to Miliband for his joke about the Bullingdon Club after Cameron insulted Balls: ‘the boy from the Bullingdon Club lectures on bullying – extraordinary’. Miliband then went on to remark if he ‘smashed any restaurants recently’.


Simon Evans is a member of Progress. He tweets @SimonEvans117


Photo: UK Parliament

Progressive centre-ground Labour politics does not come for free.

It takes time, commitment and money to build a fight against the forces of conservatism. If you value the work Progress does, please support us by becoming a member, subscriber or donating.

Our work depends on you.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Simon Evans

1 comment

  • Hon Ed Balls, MP should work on some anger management maybe. Apart from that he’s doing a fine job. Pity his mate Gordon aint around to show a bit of support these days ? Can’t get personal in the House – leave that to the likes of Dave C and his cohoorts who find it quite a larf to egg the lads and lasses on and see them squirm. Don’t take the bait – stick to the PLAN.
    A bit of lively banter is fine at school and college, but this place where Laws are made should show some decorum and respect for LAWS they make and uphold. Its not a rugger game, cheps.
    Ed and Ed still get my vote. Good lads. Needing some support from their own ranks though, I am not so much worried about the Tories and Libdem girls as about our own stalwarts.
    Gotta stick together boys and girls, the ‘fat lady aint sung yet’, and there’s many a slip twixt cup and lip…. don’t get too cocky, cock !

Sign up to our daily roundup email