Progress | Centre-left Labour politics

Beyond the ‘dented shield’

On taking power in May 2010 after years in the wilderness, Islington’s Labour group, supported by the wider party membership, embarked on a groundbreaking process, fulfilling our manifesto pledge to establish the first Fairness Commission.

Despite our sunblushed tomatoes and polenta reputation, Islington is also home to real deprivation. We are the 14th most deprived local authority area in England. Half our kids grow up in child poverty and half our older people live in fuel poverty. We have the third highest crime rate in London and the highest male suicide rate in London. We have 335 families living in severe overcrowding and a seven-year gap in life expectancy between men in the highest income group and those in the lowest income group.

This poverty scars our borough, and 13 years of Labour investment in government in Westminster hadn’t shifted the dial, in no small part down to the indolence and apathy of the ruling Lib Dems on the council.

Inspired by The Spirit Level by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett, we decided that the response to the shocking realities outlined above wasn’t merely to try to tackle poverty, but rather to tackle inequality, creating a fairer Islington that would be to the benefit of all residents.

The commission was made up of 20 cross-sector, cross-party commissioners, co-chaired by Professor Richard Wilkinson and my councillor colleague Andy Hull. Its brief was to be radical but realistic. All commissioners knew that our recommendations would shape Islington’s agenda, strategy and budget for four years, so we had to get it right. Empty promising and posturing wouldn’t do the job; we needed a plan we could put into practice.

We held a year-long consultation process consisting of seven public meetings attended by hundreds of residents. There was also a huge volume of written submissions and evidence which were analysed and collated by cross-departmental problem-solving team.

At the end of this process we pulled together a report setting out our 19 wide-ranging key recommendations, including a three-pronged strategy to tackle debt and payday lenders, a literacy drive, building more affordable homes and some profound action on employment and skills. Have a look at our website to see the full list.

We intend to deliver and expect to be held to account, with a public progress report to our communities committee every six months and a public progress report to full council every 12 months.

We have already seen the fruit of our commission. We became the first council to achieve living wage employer status, on pay ratios we have cut the pay of our chief executive by £50k, brought our cleaning staff back in-house, and opened a Citizens Advice Bureau on Upper Street which is used by 1,000 people a month. And we know we can do more.

The Islington Fairness Commission has been hugely influential, with others setting up similar bodies, including Newcastle, Liverpool and Leicester. I think part of the reason for this is that many Labour councils and councillors understand that simply ‘passporting’ central government cuts by salami-slicing budgets abrogates responsibility, and will increase apathy and disengagement – and cost them votes. Why should a Labour council take responsibility for the catastrophic decisions taken at Whitehall by Tory ministers? We need to tell our own story.

The traditional ‘dented shield’ approach of Labour councils with a Tory government won’t do it this time. I believe that if a Labour council gets out of the town hall, and engages the whole community in agreeing a vision for how services should be delivered fairly in a context of cuts, then it will have a clear roadmap for its term of office. Such a vision is crucial in telling the story of the priorities of the council to the community, providing a ‘lens’ to explain how and why difficult decisions are made, with clear policy ‘totems’ symbolising this vision.

Please drop me a line if you want to find out more about the Islington Fairness Commission or talk about setting up a Fairness Commission in your area.


Joe Caluori is a councillor in the London borough of Islington. He tweets @Croslandite

Progressive centre-ground Labour politics does not come for free.

It takes time, commitment and money to build a fight against the forces of conservatism. If you value the work Progress does, please support us by becoming a member, subscriber or donating.

Our work depends on you.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Joe Caluori


  • As the great Brigit Jones would say ” More fuckwittery”. It seems that Fairness Commissions are the new rock and roll and everyone has to have one. Even the Islamic extremist regime in Tower Hamlets has got one chaired by mega time water and pest Giles Fraser. There is nothing that the Islington commission will produce that has not already been said at the beginning of this article.

    The Tower Hamlets one is going to cost in the region of twenty grand with everyone on expenses, Fraser is to cop five of those grands for essentially a couple of weeks of talking crap. Everybody, including, those pocketing the money, knows that these scams, and that is all they are, produce nothing except a report that will be binned because there is nothing that can possibly come out of it.

    They are simply ways of aspiring politicians saying look at what we are doing, aren’t we being revolutionary and right on and giving those nasty Tories a telling off? A disgusting waste of public money.

  • ‘White van man’s’ nihilism takes us nowhere. Although I might share the cynicism of various local authority attempts at corporate branding or rebranding – we’ve had local authorities that have been ‘transformed’, ‘enabled’ or made ‘resilient’, but at least Islington’s Fairness Commission has made a serious effort at bringing in a proper academic research team aligned with some genuine public engagement. I may not personally agree with all the policy outcomes the Fairness Commission has proposed to Islington council, but it is more democratic than simply cobbling together a manifesto cooked up by out of touch party activists or paid party officials.

Sign up to our daily roundup email