Progress | Centre-left Labour politics

The broken promise budget

This is originally from the Progress Daily Email. If you like what you see and would like to sign up to receive it, click here.

One of the big political mistakes of the budget – even before the speech was given – was scheduling it for a Monday. Having it so early in the week gives parliament, thinktanks and journalists more working days to dig in to the detail this week. It may sound ridiculous, but it will certainly play a role in how this budget unravels.

The tone has already been set, with the Institute for Fiscal Studies rubbishing the claim that the deficit will be eliminated by the mid-2020s.

The other big political mistake is, of course, the promise that austerity is over. That pledge increasingly feels like Theresa May aimed solely for a day of good headlines. It simply is not a promise they can deliver while sticking to the spending commitments they have already spelled out – which include more enormous cuts to, for example, local government next year. As people see their services continue to get worse or disappear, they will, fairly, ask what happened to that promise.

It also means that when they see those cuts come in, they will view them as a choice, not a necessity. For the past eight years, the Conservatives have framed cuts as something they have to do, rather than something they want to do. Now they claim the belt-tightening years are over, it is impossible to argue that services they continue to decimate are anything other than an ideological agenda.

As Brexit – a topic curiously absent from most of the budget – begins to bite, the lack of a sunny uplands will not only be seen as a government failure, but an intended broken promise too.

Not that it makes this week easy for Labour, necessarily. We have seen already some disagreement and, well, confusion, mainly, over whether or not we back enormous tax cuts. Sometimes, it seems, the progressive arguments need more clarity.

On that note: make sure you vote in the current strategy board elections. Just search for ‘Progress – Strategy Board Elections 2018’ in your email inbox.

– Conor Pope, deputy editor

Latest on Progress

A civil rights protest in Washington DC – an important part of the history of the struggle for Black liberation

Shaping tomorrow’s history

As Black History month comes to a close, Progress activist Abdi Duale explains how we can use education to shape the history books of the future

Read now >>>


Trump is known for telling myths

The age of myth

Human beings need narrative to make sense of the world, but is the new era of communication creating a world of myth, asks Peter Lassey

Read now >>>

Progress strategy board candidate articles

We will be publishing up to two articles by all candidates standing for the current strategy board elections over the coming weeks.

The Joke is on us

The chancellor’s budget was full of weak jokes, but the joke is really on us, writes Paul Brant


Centre-left politics at the heart of local government

Local government is the cradle of innovation on the centre-left, writes James Beckles


Britain’s generational fightback

The fight to ‘re-order the world around us’ begins now, writes David Harley


The centre-left’s missed trick to the affordable housing crisis

Smartly designed supply-side policy can provide more genuinely affordable homes for low-income tenants, writes Christopher Worrall

Voting is now open in the Progress strategy board elections. The Progress strategy board exists to guide the work of Progress, and ensure the strategic aims of the organisation.

Click here to see your candidates.

The Progressive Britain Podcast

How should the Windrush scandal change the way we talk about immigration and citizenship? Has Donald Trump emboldened racism in the UK? And would a People’s Vote see a resurgence of the far right?

Conor PopeHenna Shah and David Lammy discuss in this episode to mark Black History Month 2018.

Listen >>>

The Progressive Britain Podcast on Conservative party conference

Five things to read today

Key points from budget 2018 – at a glance
Richard Partington and Peter Walker, Guardian

As A Proud Student Activist, I Cannot Stand By And Watch The Tories Ruin This Country – It’s Time For A People’s Vote
Ellie James, HuffPost UK Young Voices

4 things to know about Jair Bolsonaro, Brazil’s new far-right president
Jen Kirby, Vox

LGBT activists have a new weapon against Russia’s ‘gay propaganda’ law: YouTube influencers 
Jessica Bateman, Wired

Let’s celebrate LGBT+ leadership at all levels 
Andrew Pakes, Prospect

Sign up to this email


Progressive centre-ground Labour politics does not come for free.

It takes time, commitment and money to build a fight against the forces of conservatism. If you value the work Progress does, please support us by becoming a member, subscriber or donating.

Our work depends on you.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Conor Pope

is online features editor at Four Four Two Magazine

Sign up to our daily roundup email