State of emergency: Cameron’s very British coup | Angela Eagle MP The sky’s the limit for Labour’s women | Helen Gibson PMQs are back | Melanie Smallman Housing is key | Lisa Homan What is the point of the Lords now? | Glenys Thornton
Latest magazine

September 2010

September 2010



Columns
Paul's week in politics Paul's week in politics
Paul Richards
Red Wedge Red Wedge
Dividing the Lib-Con coalition
Kate comments Kate comments
Kate Green MP
Commons people Commons people
Jonathan Reynolds MP
Life in the Lords Life in the Lords
Dianne Hayter and guest writers
Stateside story Stateside story
James Plunkett
Union matters Union matters
Hannah Blythyn
Scotland Scotland
Judith Fisher
Holyrood 2011 Holyrood 2011
Kezia Dugdale
Wales Wales
Nick Smith MP
Young progressives Young progressives
David Chaplin & Jamie McMahon
The economy The economy
Rachel Reeves MP & Ben Fox
Colombia Colombia
Maria Carolina Latorre
School governors' network School governors' network
News and views from the education frontline
Third Sector Third Sector
Tom Levitt
The Politics of Poverty The Politics of Poverty
Steve Cockburn
From the grassroots From the grassroots
Louisa Thomson
Latest comments

"Yearly tax increases on cigarettes had no impact in reducing...
Ian Willmore (London)
08/09/2010 | 16:49

Time for an elected house of Lords. And elected with proportional...
Eveline V (Liverpool)
08/09/2010 | 16:42

"A belief in the innate worth of human beings, particular...
Tom Miller (London)
08/09/2010 | 01:24

this is a con-dem con con to reduce constituencies,why else...
r g true (treherbert rhondda)
07/09/2010 | 21:42

Links

Columns

Scotland

Scotland Judith Fisher

Judith Fisher is the Research Co-ordinator of Strathclyde Business School. She writes here in a personal capacity. Photo: Ianan 2008

Independence back up the agenda?

Judith Fisher
03 Sep 2010 09:35

Alex Salmond believes that independence will be a ‘major, perhaps dominating, issue' in the run up to the election in May. Initially this appears a peculiar stance for him to take, given that support for independence in Scotland is currently sitting at less than a third.



read the full column »

SNP threat to education support

Judith Fisher
06 Aug 2010 09:00

The future of the education maintenance allowance (EMA) which was rolled out across Scotland in 2004-5, providing 16-19 year olds with up to £30 a week to stay at school or go on to college, is looking increasingly rocky.



read the full column »

We must harness the opportunity for radical policy

Judith Fisher
28 Jun 2010 10:13

Judith Fisher says Scottish Labour must embrace new ideas in their manifesto for next years Holyrood elections.



read the full column »

Scotland in the ConDem nation

Judith Fisher
04 Jun 2010 09:54

Scotland doesn't like the Tories. We hold this truth to be self-evident. So how is the new coalition government viewed north of the border and what is the likely impact on next year's Holyrood elections?



read the full column »

The view from Scotland

Judith Fisher
07 May 2010 12:11

As I write, only one constituency in Scotland has yet to declare. Your correspondent has notoriously bad judgement when it comes to election results, but it's fair to say that few were expecting the Labour swing witnessed in Scotland last night.



read the full column »

Losing the wrong battle

Judith Fisher
29 Apr 2010 10:57

Well it has finally happened. Our first minister's ego has grown so large, that the SNP feel it just can't be contained in Scotland any longer



read the full column »

The budget’s impact in Scotland

Judith Fisher
25 Mar 2010 11:49

Yesterday's budget provided both benefits and opportunities for Scotland, as Alistair Darling sought to improve provision for pensioners, families with young children and the young unemployed whilst stimulating sustainable economic growth, all within a highly restrictive economic climate.



read the full column »

Response to Jim Murphy faith speech: no faith in those values

Judith Fisher
25 Feb 2010 09:41

A few weeks ago I participated in a panel organised by the National LGBT Forum on ‘Race, Religion and Belief'. I was the token Christian. The first question I was asked centred on comments made by the Pope recently on same-sex adoption and the new equalities legislation.



read the full column »

SNP cut will reopen Scots brain drain and harm poorer graduates

Judith Fisher
27 Jan 2010 10:38

Scottish Enterprise have announced the axing of a scheme with a proven track record of getting thousands of graduates into work. The Graduates for Business scheme arranges paid work placements for participants. Around 250 graduates a year have participated in paid internships of between three months and a year, with two-thirds ending up employed by the firms involved and the majority of the rest gaining an equivalent job as a result of the placement.



read the full column »

With a series of meaty policy announcements Scottish Labour are increasingly looking like a government in waiting

Judith Fisher
18 Dec 2009 10:39

This month saw the publication of The Literacy Commission Report in Scotland. The Commission, set up by the Scottish Labour party but consisting of an independent group of educationalists, academics, business people and authors, has spent the last eighteen months investigating Scotland's literacy problem.



read the full column »

Scottish Labour must now articulate their vision of the kind of Scotland they want to use these new powers to create

Judith Fisher
26 Nov 2009 10:47

This week, the UK government announced a list of new powers it wants to transfer from Westminster to the Scottish parliament, and a few that it wants to transfer from Holyrood back to Westminster, under its response to the Calman Commission review of devolution. This comes ahead of the SNP government setting out its own white paper on independence, which is due to take place on Monday, St Andrew’s Day.



read the full column »

Claiming for asylum is a human right

Judith Fisher
28 Oct 2009 13:56

On October 13, Phil Woolas, minister of state for borders and immigration, announced major changes to the procedure for changing asylum which have particular repercussions for asylum seekers in Scotland.



read the full column »

The SNP have yet to figure out that the purpose of governing is meant to be improving people’s lives

Judith Fisher
24 Sep 2009 14:29

Last week, the SNP made their annual budget announcement.

The Scottish government outlined plans to cut schools funding by £2.7m, the enterprise budget by £76m, with housing and regeneration the biggest loser, facing cuts of £253m. The money to be spent on affordable housing will go down from £525m this year to £352m next year.



read the full column »

Communities are suffering as the SNP raids the Highlands and Islands Enterprise budget

Judith Fisher
24 Aug 2009 10:22

Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE) is one of Europe’s most successful development agencies, with a track record of adopting a more holistic approach to economic development, supporting initiatives which support the wider community as a route to stimulating growth.



read the full column »

Is it time for a Scottish referendum on the monarchy?

Judith Fisher
23 Jul 2009 12:55

It's silly season at Holyrood, and you can't get much sillier than the royal family.



read the full column »

At a time of national belt-tightening pressure is mounting on Alex Salmond to justify spending on the Council of Economic Advisers

Judith Fisher
24 Jun 2009 11:42

At a time when most people are feeling the pinch, pressure is mounting on Alex Salmond to justify spending on the Council of Economic Advisers.



read the full column »

A decade of Scottish devolution

Judith Fisher
28 May 2009 13:00

The Scottish media this month has been full of coverage to mark the first decade of devolution, and with a new book published on those 10 years, ‘Uncharted Territory’ by Hamish Macdonell, it seemed timely to look back at what those years have held.



read the full column »

We must not forget that Labour is a movement, not just a party

Judith Fisher
22 Apr 2009 10:40

This week has seen the annual conference of the Scottish Trades Union Congress under the theme of ‘Rebuilding Collective Prosperity’.



read the full column »

The SNP have failed again to put their money where their mouth is

Judith Fisher
26 Feb 2009 11:24

During the 2007 election, the SNP made cutting class sizes to a maximum of 18 in the first three years of primary school a flagship manifesto pledge.



read the full column »

The budget proposed by the SNP is grossly inadequate in the face of the current financial crisis

Judith Fisher
29 Jan 2009 11:46

The Scottish government’s budget for the coming year has been rejected by the Scottish parliament. The budget fell on the vote of the presiding officer after the vote tied at 64 votes apiece.



read the full column »

The SNP government is failing to protect Scottish families from home repossession

Judith Fisher
18 Dec 2008 13:34

One of the most fundamental human needs is that of decent shelter, but, as the collapse of the housing market continues, Scottish families are finding that they do not have the same protections from repossession as their counterparts in the rest of the UK.



read the full column »

Reclaim the night

Judith Fisher
27 Nov 2008 12:02

This week, hundreds of women (and a fair few men) took part in the annual ‘Reclaim the Night’ march around Glasgow’s West End. The march, organised by Glasgow Rape Crisis, is a declaration of the unacceptability of any violence against women, but particularly focuses on sexual violence.



read the full column »

The financial crisis has exposed the gulf between Labour and the SNP

Judith Fisher
24 Oct 2008 13:04

It's not often I find myself agreeing with George Galloway. Last week may indeed have been only the second such occasion, when I read his pronouncement that the current economic situation meant that ‘Alex Salmond and the whole separatist project is a goose which has been cooked and there's no disguising it'. He's right.



read the full column »

The truth behind the SNP's local income tax

Judith Fisher
29 Sep 2008 12:40

The referendum on the creation of a Scottish parliament posed two separate questions to the electorate: did we want a parliament; and if so, did we want it to have tax-varying powers? The result was an overwhelming yes to the first question, and a very definite yes to the second.



read the full column »

The race for the Scottish Labour leadership is between three distinctive personalities

Judith Fisher
21 Aug 2008 16:41

I've been a member of the Labour party for more than a decade, and yet, despite the four ‘elected' leaders we've had in Scotland, this is the first leadership contest I've had any say in.



read the full column »

After Glasgow East: Labour needs a message of hope

Judith Fisher
25 Jul 2008 11:31

So, last night we lost one of the safest seats in Scotland. The Scottish Labour campaign was well organised. Activists turned out to do the work. We had a great candidate. And we lost.



read the full column »

The unwelcome reality of an SNP government is beginning to bite

Judith Fisher
27 Jun 2008 16:36

This week sees the end of the year at Holyrood, with parliament now in recess until September.



read the full column »

Why the SNP are scared of a referendum on independence

Judith Fisher
22 May 2008 12:04

You know a political rammy has really kicked off when something happening in Scotland makes the UK news, so the hot topic this month has to be pushing ahead with a referendum on independence.

The SNP are a political party, some may say an overdeveloped pressure group, with a single unifying aim, Scottish independence. However, in the run up to the last election they became gradually quieter on their core motivation until, a year into their government, the only time we hear about the magical powers of an independent Scotland is when the SNP are blaming Westminster for their own inabilities to deliver any of their election commitments.



read the full column »

Scottish Labour’s primary experiment

Judith Fisher
24 Apr 2008 00:00

The Scottish Labour party is a queer beast. An organisation firmly rooted in tradition, our policies may have constantly urged progress and social innovation, but the infrastructure that has supported this constant call for change remains shaped by procedures developed at the birth of our movement.

We have much to be proud of in our heritage: huge social advances; the individual role of giants such as Keir Hardie; and the cultural legacy of the contribution we've made in international solidarity, for example during the Spanish Civil War, continues with us through our music and banners.



read the full column »

Can Labour challenge society's confusion between wants and needs?

Judith Fisher
27 Mar 2008 00:00

In opposition, a party has two functions: to critically scrutinise the government; and to develop and communicate its own ideas and philosophy to offer an alternative vision of how the country should be run.

Fulfilling the first of these functions is now relatively straightforward for the Scottish Labour party, as community groups across the country are becoming steadily more vocal about budget cuts and their impact on services, and with the SNP's plans to introduce an expensive, unwieldy and unjust local income tax, it appears the only problem these days in criticising the government is the number of hours in the day.

 



read the full column »

It's now clear: Scotland has a centre-right government elected by stealth

Judith Fisher
20 Feb 2008 00:00

Pre-devolution, it was relatively straightforward for the SNP to portray themselves strikingly differently to different pockets of the electorate: Tartan Tories in provincial Perth and the spiritual heirs of Red Clydeside in Govan.

With the advent of the Scottish Parliament, and the SNP as the main opposition party, things became marginally more complicated as the demanding electorate now expected them to have more than one policy. The SNP, generously, dealt with this by adopting two, entirely detached, policy platforms. Their approach to economic policy was to buy wholesale into the rightwing myth that lowering taxes would increase investment in public services. Meanwhile, in a land far, far away, the other face of their party was jumping on every populist bandwagon going, from free school meals for the hummus-favouring children of the middle classes, to opposition to the private finance initiative. Underneath all this lurked the SNP's murky approach to equalities issues, with their acceptance of half-a-million pounds from strident homophobe Brian Souter to fund their election campaign, and their backing of the right of Catholic adoption agencies to turn away gay couples.



read the full column »

While the SNP blunders through its honeymoon, Scottish Labour is quietly renewing

Judith Fisher
25 Jan 2008 00:00

Last year was an eventful one in Scottish politics, with the Scottish National Party forming a minority government, and Scottish Labour electing a new leader, Wendy Alexander. It is now becoming clear what living under an SNP government will mean for the Scottish people. Broken promises, financial mismanagement and a prioritisation of the whims of the wealthy over the needs of the vulnerable, all look set to characterise their style of governance.

The SNP have produced a draft budget, which, with the support of the Tories, has now passed its first stage in parliament. The big achievement, supposedly, in this budget, is the agreement of local authorities to freeze council tax, a move which benefits high earners, but with no financial benefit whatsoever for those on the lowest incomes. What will impact on low earners will be the subsequent cut in services and the removal of ring-fencing agreed by the SNP in order to broker the deal with local authorities.



read the full column »